We all have an ultimate first-date story: A tale of a first meeting that left us feeling blissful—or like we wanted to crawl under the covers and not come out for days. Tell us your best first-date story—good or bad—and you could win a pair of tickets to the second annual Buy Your Own Bachelor (BYOB) auction at McCurdy’s Comedy Theater on Tuesday, Sept. 20.  Attendees will be able bid on a bevy of eligible men and fun date packages, and all proceeds benefit the American Cancer Society’s Making Strides Against Breast Cancer Walk on Oct. 22. It’s sure to be a fun, lively event!

(And for those of you who are married but still have a great story, don’t fret: You can bid at the auction, but opt out of going on the date with the bachelor and take your spouse, instead.)

Simply leave a comment below with the tale of your ultimate first date experience; winners will be notified by email on Friday, Sept. 16. Good luck!